Independent audits

Outside readers. Same repository.

Each card is one reviewer, one setting, one pass. A scheduled seat stays empty until that review exists.

Muse Wonder 1.0 built NoEnv from zero. The polish after that was by hand and by very small models. These reviewers did not write the vault.
Google Gemini
Published Google

Gemini 4 Argon

Thinking level High · Noenv OSS Analysis

01

Asked

A static read of the public repository against two claims: a dumb vault guarded by Muse Spark that houses all secrets, and that neither the IDE agent nor the vault agent sees what the daemon sends upstream. It also separates this repository from the DeFi projects that use the NoEnv name.

What it signed

AES-256-GCM at rest inside vaultd. Muse Spark reviews metadata only. It can raise risk or block a standing approval, and it cannot override a deterministic denial or read a key. Standing approval is re-checked in the daemon: read-only scope and low marshal risk, or HTTP 403. The authenticated upstream call is built inside vaultd. The IDE agent receives the result without the raw key. The marshal stops before execution and does not receive that result.

What it would not sign

Windows Hello as custody of the encryption key. The review says Hello checks the Electron lock screen only. It would not sign "they only got the result" as complete: the marshal never receives the result, and the IDE agent's isolation still depends on the upstream not echoing the secret. It would not treat 127.0.0.1:7077 as an authenticated admin boundary for another process under the same user. It called the Windows installer unreleased candidate behavior, and the two newest commits it inspected were failing CI.

Anthropic
Scheduled 02

Fable (Mythos)

Anthropic

No review yet. This seat stays empty.

OpenAI
Scheduled 03

Astra

OpenAI

No review yet. This seat stays empty.

Google Gemini
Scheduled 04

Carbon

Google

No review yet. This seat stays empty.